MARCH

STOKENHAM PARISH COUNCIL

MINUTES OF THE MEETING

HELD ON 20TH MARCH 2008 IN THE

STOKENHAM PARISH HALL

 

PRESENT:

COUNCILLORS:

 

P.  GREENING

J. ANSELL

P. ARUNDELL

R. FOSS

B. IRELAND

R. BATES

R. WARDEN

N. TOLCHARD

A. VALE

MRS C. NUTTALL-SMITH

J. BAVERSTOCK (also District Councillor)

J. BRAZIL (County Councillor) - Personal

 

Also in attendance: Clerk – Mrs G. Claydon

Cllr. M. Long – Salcombe Town Council

Cllr. R. Moore – Salcombe Town Council

 

APOLOGIES:

COUNCILLORS

 

D. WOOD - Illness

W. HARWOOD - Personal

 

1.         DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

 

Councillors were reminded of their responsibility to continually update their Notice of Registerable Interests and invited to state whether they had a personal or prejudicial interest in any matter to be discussed during this meeting.  None

 

2.         OPEN FORUM

 

Eric Heavisides noted the maintenance works at the bus shelters were a job well done but was concerned with regard to the amount of debris left behind the Carehouse Cross Shelter.  The Clerk is to request the decorators to remove such.  He went on to enquire as to who should carry out maintenance on the bench sited at the Torcross viewpoint as it was in desperate need of renovation.  Ownership is unknown but as this area is maintained by the AONB team the clerk will enquire.

 

The Chair outlined historic issues raised by bathers and boat users and outlined why the item with regard to Torcross buoys was once again on the agenda.

 

Martin Collins personally felt that a line of buoys should be in place and would not get tangled with boats.  With a demarcation it assists locals in advising visitors of the risks and perameters and therefore the community marshal such usage themselves.  If no line of buoys are in force he felt that holiday boat users from Torquay and adjacent tourist areas would tear up and down Torcross beach.

 

Chris Long agreed with Martin’s comments and felt that this issue appeared to go back once again to the insurance and liability aspect that District had raised before.  The Chair advised that Nick Hodgson had initially felt such was a problem but having checked with District legal department advised that they could find a way around insurance.

 

Martin Collins noted that when Torcross residents had come together previously in a meeting it was decided to recommend that such delineation revert to a line of buoys.

 

Dist. Cllr. Baverstock agreed that £1250 had been allocated to a line of buoys for the 2008/09 season and it was decided that he should meet with the Harbourmaster and one of the senior lifeguards.   Cllr. Baverstock therefore wrote to Paul Stubbs but he was unable to attend so Chris Venmore was invited as a boat user.  A meeting therefore took place 10 days ago.  Cllr. Baverstock noted that from the outset there was considerable concern with regard to putting buoys out as beach and boat users pay little or no attention to buoys.  Following the on beach meeting the group view was that there should be no buoys placed for summer 2008.  He further advised that the buoys are difficult to anchor and move around in swell.  Also by placing buoys District are indicating they are accepting liability for beach and sea incidents and noted that the insurance company would prefer even lifebuoys removed as well.  New signage will be placed to spell out responsibility to beach and sea users.  It was also noted that there had been few if no fatalities over recent years.

 

Cllr. Vale arrived.

 

Cllr. Baverstock continued that there is no means whereby the line of buoys can be enforced. He advised that the lifeguards are to be placed at the middle car park and thus give coverage for three beaches.  He further noted that in an AONB the beach at Torcross looks much more attractive without large pink buoys floating off the beach and that he was fully aware of safety issues having spent a number of years on the beach safety committee.  This was not a financial issue as money is already allocated.

 

A resident enquired why was Cllr. Ireland as the Torcross representative was not invited to the meeting.  Cllr. Baverstock advised that no councillors were invited as this was an officer meeting.  The Chair noted that he had initially felt that the meeting convened to decide where such buoys were to be placed.  Cllr. Baverstock advised that he was not wrong as this was the intention.

 

Another resident noted that Torcross beach is unique due to the fact that there is high water so close to the edge of the beach and although buoys might look messy he felt there should be buoys.  Due to such deep waters just off the shore very powerful boats can come in within 3yards of the shoreline but buoys deter these speed boats coming so close.  A single row of buoys were not previously roped together and if put down should be no more than 30 metres off low mean water.  It was noted that all the signage would be of no consequence as visiting boat users cannot read the signs.

 

Cllr. Ansell advised that when this matter was previously discussed at the Community and Environment Committee it was agreed that if buoys did nothing more than warn boat owners that they might hit somebody they have done their job.  Cllr. Ireland and Chris Long agreed.

 

Pc Mutton arrived and was congratulated by the Chair on the way the police have recently been working with the Neighbourhood Watch.  Pc Mutton advised that last month he was advised that there were 20 offences in Stokenham Parish.  He had advised at the time that he felt the figure were high/incorrect and in actual fact the figure was 12.  However since the 1st Feb there had been 17 offences reported.  The police have had people in custody for a few weeks and some property had been recovered with several arrested, several charged and more to come.  He thanked the community for their assistance as these crimes had been dealt with through good local information.

 

Cllr. Warden enquired whether the police would be handing over parking duties at the end of March and if so whether the police still retained all normal powers to control parking offences.  The changeover will now be the beginning of May and Pc Mutton is concerned that there may be a non fully functional period but when things are up and running the police have no jurisdiction over yellow lines although continue to act for obstruction etc.  Parking attendants will primarily be in towns and therefore there were concerns as to ability to deal with offences in rural areas.  Cllr. Tolchard noted that as the local authority are taking over will such staff work 9-5p.m.  Pc Mutton felt that as charges are in force over night he would think there must be some overtime.

 

Cllr. Warden advised that from discussions with the Leader of District, John Tucker, when this service is devolved to County and District they will then outsource to a private company.

 

3.         MINUTES

 

The Minutes of the meeting dated 21st February 2008 were approved by all present and duly signed by the Chairman as a true and correct record.   

 

4.         TORCROSS BUOYS

 

Councillors were advised that a meeting having taken place with the Harbour Master, an RNLI representative, Chris Venmore and District Cllr. Baverstock the group decided not to lay any buoys at Torcross for the forthcoming season.  Parish Council were concerned as they had been advised by District that funding was in place within the budget for such.

 

Cllr Foss noted his disappointment with this decision and as chair of the AONB Committee acknowledged that the buoys were not aesthetic.  He went on to advise that he felt that signs on the promenade were of no use but that users will stop and consider buoys.  As District take money out of the car parks and such buoys would only cost £1250 he felt this decision should not have been overturned.  Cllr. Ansell felt that the Community & Environment Committee had considered this matter and made the right decision.  Many comments were received and there was general disquiet with this matter.

 

Cllr. Baverstock refuted comments made and explained his reasoning.  He advised that he had taken on board what had been said this evening and advised that the most salient factor was the insurance aspect that could render District vulnerable.  Cllr. Baverstock advised he would contact District legal department and determine the exact position with regard to liability.  As District Councillor he noted he had to consider legal restrictions of and other such factors.

 

It was AGREED that parish council should object to the decision not to lay the buoys and accordingly write to Paula Brooks of Strategic Operations reflecting the concerns and views of councillors and residents.

 

5.         PARISH PLAN

 

A website has been created by Devon County Council collating all the information within all parish and town plans across Devon.  This website will be available for all to use as a tool to inform how funding or assistance was accessed and each community put in place their aspirations.  Now that the information has been uploaded the projects within the plan need updating across the various layers of information and it was AGREED that Cllr. Greening would carry out such for Stokenham.

 

6.         LISTENING EVENTS – DEVON COUNTY COUNCIL

 

Devon County Council are holding Parish Listening Events across Devon and the one closest to this parish is on 11th April 2008 7 – 9p.m. at Ivybridge Town Hall.  It was AGREED that Cllr Foss and Cllr. Warden or Cllr. Vale would attend to represent Stokenham.

 

7.         CURRENT LEGISLATION TRAINING

 

Councillors were advised of the important legislation update training at Exminster on 5th June 2008 at a cost of £40 per head.

 

8.         COMMITTEES

 

The following Minutes and recommendations were received from the Committees

 

(a)       PLANNING COMMITTEE – The Minutes of Committee dated 18th February and 3rd March 2008 were noted having been agreed at planning committee.

 

(b)       COMMUNITY & ENVIRONMENT – The Minutes of the committee held on 10th March 2008 were PROPOSED by Cllr. Ansell as a true and correct record and SECONDED by Cllr. Ireland before being signed by the Chair

 

(c)       FINANCE STAFFING & GENERAL PURPOSES – The Minutes of the bi-monthly committee held on Monday 17th March 2008 were PROPOSED by Cllr. Baverstock and SECONDED by Mrs Nuttall-Smith before being signed by the Chair.

 

9.         REPORTS

 

Matters around the parish requiring notification or action by the Clerk:

 

It was noted that the hedges at Simla, Kellaton required cutting back – the clerk is to write accordingly.

 

            CLERK’S REPORT

 

            DEVON ASSOCIATION OF PARISH COUNCILS

 

Councillors were advised that DAPC would be running a visit to the new community centre at Ivybridge and those interested were requested to notify DAPC.  An update on the new criteria for Quality Status was also mentioned along with new legislation that effectively debars co-opted councillors from holding ‘Chair’.

 

            COLERIDGE ASSOCIATION OF PARISH COUNCILS

 

The Chair and Vice Chair had attended the meeting held at Sherford Community Hall with guest speaker David Incoll.  He advised that District find it difficult to recruit staff at present due to area restrictions.  Also he advised that Paula Brooks and Chris Lucas at Distrcit are working hard to address such lack of communication issues.  It was noted that the recycling is due for a change again as aims have been achieved but at a cost and thus economically they cannot continue.  David Incoll advised that affordable homes were a priority but noted that the new planning system was holding the process up.  The structure of a new authority is currently being debated but David Incoll personally felt such changes should be rural based and not a Plymouth/Torbay division.  It was noted that evidence must be produced to back up proposals and suggested that Government thinking might be to set election dates to coincide with the European Elections.

 

Thereafter local reports of each parish council were given. 

 

            AREA OF OUTSTANDING NATURAL BEAUTY

 

Cllr. Foss noted that this group were struggling as their money is being cut by County, District and Natural England.  There is at present core funding to keep staff but nothing for projects.  Cllr Foss asserted that private companies should be approached as such partnership support would assist company environmental targets.

 

            SLAPTON LINE BUSINESS FORUM

 

Cllr. Baverstock advised that he had attended this meeting which attracted 30 prominent business people from around the parish.  A detailed map of the alternative parish routes was provided and considered.  He did however feel it was difficult to analysise the difference between the Slapton Line Forum and Business Forum and the aim of the meeting although it was decided that the forum would continue.  It was noted that there appeared too much publicity and opinion with regard to the road being closed when the local opinion was about how they should keep the road open.

 

            TREE WARDEN SCHEME

 

Cllr. Vale as Tree Warden noted that the AONB had been partly funding the Tree Warden facility and due to change have now withdrawn their funding and thus the Tree Warden Scheme looked to as though it might cease. 

 

 

 

            COMMUNITY INTERNET ACCESS

 

Cllr. Warden congratulated the webmaster for facilitating this and was sorry to see finish due to lack of uptake and the end of specific funding.  It was however hoped to provide such access through alternative routes such as evening Councillors Surgeries.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               10.       DISTRICT COUNCILLOR’S REPORT

 

Cllr. Baverstock advised that District have discussed the Devon Boundary Review.  Meetings are taking place daily between the Boundary Com and various Districts.  County are attempting to group all Districts together and advance on a united front.  He went on to explain the current thinking and when such would be in place.

 

He noted that the Devon Concessionary Bus Partnership had received completed forms in November and to date no passes have been received.  The message is please be patient and they should be available in the next week or so.

 

Cllr. Baverstock advised that there is a new corporate policy in District council that stipulates when officers must reply to enquiries by.

 

11.       COUNTY COUNCILLOR’S REPORT

 

No report provided.

 

12.       FINANCE AND CHEQUES

 

Current Account                      £    885.62 

Instant Savers (1)                    £24368.03

Instant Savers (2)                    £  3213.50

 

Lloyds Transferred : £5,000.00

 

Cheques:

 

001456 Eclipse Internet – Community and Parish internet (February): £36.98

001457 Mrs G. Claydon – Clerk’s wages £1267.19

001458 In. Rev. –  Tax and Nat. Ins: £1.62

001459 Ms. A. Ball – Bus Shelter Cleaning: £70.00

001460 P. Ball – Bus Shelter Cleaning: £70.00

001461 E. Luscombe – Bus Shelter Cleaning: £70.00

001462 P. Stone – Bus Shelter Cleaning: £70.00

001463 Helping Hands – Bus Shelter Maintenance: £2,250.13

001464 Stokenham Parish Hall Com. – IT and Craft Fair Hire of Hall & Elec. meter: £50.00

001465 Concorde Copiers – Maintenance: £3.64

001466 Eclipse Internet – Community and Parish Internet (March) £36.98

001467 Concorde Copiers – Maintenance: £0.81

001468 British Telecom – Council Internet & phone: £83.94

001469 British Telecom – Community Internet: £55.15

001470 Sea Shanty – Creative Crafts Training Sundries: £50.00

001471 G. Claydon – Travel and Sundries: £271.54

 

Received: Nil

 

13.       POINTS OF INFORMATION

 

The Boundary Committee – Structural Review in Devon literature and poster.

Devon Strategic Framework for Health and Social Care

Devontalk – Devon County Council

SHDC Executive Forward Plan March 2008.

Voluntary Vine March/April 2008.

Village Green x 4.

                                                                                   

14.       NEXT MEETING

 

The next full parish council meeting will be held on Thursday 17th April 2008 at 7.30p.m. in the Stokenham Parish Hall.

 

Meeting finished:  p.m.

 

Signed ………………………   Dated:         April 2008.

 

COUNCIL